Impostor Syndrome Is a Fraud

Author: Majken Lorelei Matzau

Impostor syndrome is spoken of everywhere. It has become one of the most popular explanations for why capable, accomplished people feel secretly undeserving of their success. The term has the ring of a clinical diagnosis. It suggests that something is wrong inside the individual experiencing it. And that suggestion, I believe, is itself a kind of fraud.

A Label That Blames the Individual

Throughout our lives we are tested, measured, and ranked on our performance – in school, in the workplace, in every arena that matters socially. We are educated into the belief that our value is determined by what we produce and achieve. Our inner worth becomes confused with our external output. And when that confusion is deeply enough embedded, no achievement ever quite feels real – because the part of us that knows our value independent of performance has been systematically undermined.

Calling this a “syndrome” locates the problem inside the person. It implies that capable individuals have some psychological defect that prevents them from accurately recognizing their own competence. But the feeling of inadequacy in high-performing people is not a private pathology. It is a collective imbalance – the predictable result of a culture that has collapsed the distinction between who we are and what we do.

The System, Not the Self

The educational and organizational systems that produce impostor feelings are remarkably consistent: external validation as the primary measure of worth, constant performance pressure, insufficient acknowledgment of the process in favor of outcomes, and a fundamental message – repeated often enough to be believed – that you are only as valuable as your last achievement.

In this environment, feeling like a fraud is not a cognitive distortion. It is a rational response to having one's intrinsic value repeatedly ignored.

What Actually Needs Changing

Rather than offering individuals courses in confidence-building or imposter management, what is needed is a fundamental shift in how organizations and institutions measure and communicate value. Not “how do we fix these people” but “how did we build a culture in which so many people feel they are not enough?”

Impostor syndrome is not a syndrome. It is the symptom of a system that teaches people to doubt the validity of their own experience. The fraud is not in the person who feels it – the fraud is in calling it a personal problem when it is a collective one.

Sign up for my

mailing list

And receive the following:

• The e-book "3 Stories from Majken Lorelei's work with Top Executives"
• VIP invitations to my events
• Exclusive insights, articles & new releases